Is Hate Speech Free Speech?

So much has been on my mind this past week, and it felt SO good to get some of it out in my last post. I want to keep doing that here, just sharing what I’ve been thinking through. One question in particular has stuck with me: is hate speech free speech? That question has been front and center ever since Charlie Kirk was murdered. In the aftermath, I watched videos and read comments of people celebrating his death. My first reaction was grief. Then came shock, then anger… and finally, the question: what should the consequences be for people who take part in that kind of evil? And almost immediately, the flip side appeared: videos of people crying into their cameras, saying they’d been fired for their celebrations and claiming their “free speech” rights were violated. But were they?

In America, free speech means the government can’t punish you for your words. You can’t be jailed for criticizing leaders, questioning policies or sharing your faith. That is the heart of the First Amendment, but it doesn’t mean every single thing a person says is protected. The Supreme Court has drawn clear lines: true threats aren’t protected (such as telling someone you are going to kill them), incitement to imminent violence is not protected, (such as urging a crowd to riot immediately), solicitation of crimes is not protected, (such as encouraging someone to commit murder or fraud) and defamation is not protected, (when false statements presented as fact harm another person’s reputation. But offensive opinions, harsh criticism, and even words most people consider hateful are protected under the Constitution. In fact, the Supreme Court upheld the right to burn the American flag in Texas v. Johnson (1989). Many saw that act as deeply offensive and unpatriotic, but the Court ruled that offensive expression is still free speech. The principle was simple: if government can punish one kind of unpopular speech, then no speech is truly safe…

I’m keeping the rest of this update for my Substack family. The full post continues below for subscribers: